Thanksgiving is a time to gather, reflect, and, let’s be honest, sometimes spar over politics at the dinner table. Few names stir as much discussion—and division—as that of Donald Trump. For many on the left, the question isn’t just how to oppose his ideas but how to reclaim the narrative he has so effectively dominated. This Thanksgiving, let’s explore how progressive ideals can be framed in ways that dismantle Trumpism’s appeal while advancing a more inclusive vision of America.

Trump’s Playbook: Emotion Over Substance

One of Trump’s most effective strategies has been his ability to distill complex issues into simple, emotionally charged messages. “Make America Great Again” is less a policy agenda than a nostalgic appeal, a yearning for an undefined past that resonates deeply with many Americans. It’s a powerful tool—but one that can be countered.

Progressives must recognize the emotional underpinnings of Trump’s rhetoric and respond in kind. For every claim of “greatness” rooted in exclusion, there’s an opportunity to advocate for collective progress. Instead of dwelling solely on what’s wrong, the left can inspire hope for what’s possible: a thriving middle class, equitable opportunities, and a nation strengthened by its diversity.

Hijacking Trump’s Talking Points

Trump has often positioned himself as the champion of the “forgotten man and woman,” railing against elites while fostering policies that disproportionately benefit the wealthy. This contradiction presents an opening for progressives: embrace his populist themes but ground them in real economic justice.

Take, for instance, Trump’s emphasis on manufacturing jobs and trade. Instead of dismissing these concerns, progressives could expand the conversation to include renewable energy jobs, workforce retraining, and domestic innovation. By reframing his rhetoric around job creation as an opportunity for green growth and infrastructure investment, the left can meet voters where they are while steering the conversation toward solutions that align with progressive values.

The Art of Outperforming the Showman

Perhaps Trump’s greatest skill is his ability to dominate media narratives. Every tweet, rally, and soundbite is crafted to provoke outrage and ensure he remains the center of attention. While his opponents often respond with indignation, this approach risks amplifying his message rather than countering it.

Instead, progressives should focus on proactive storytelling that underscores their own agenda. Highlight stories of Americans whose lives have improved because of progressive policies—whether it’s affordable healthcare, student loan relief, or expanded access to childcare. Celebrate these successes loudly and often, providing a sharp contrast to the divisive rhetoric that fuels Trump’s base.

Thanksgiving as a Time for Reconnection

Ultimately, the battle for America’s soul isn’t won through political gamesmanship but through genuine connection. Thanksgiving reminds us of the importance of shared values, even amid our differences. As we sit around the table this year, let’s commit to listening—not just to those who agree with us but to those whose experiences differ from our own.

Trumpism has thrived in part because it offers a sense of belonging to those who feel left behind. Progressives must offer an alternative vision, one rooted in empathy, equity, and hope. By reframing the conversation and reclaiming the narrative, we can build a future that honors the best of what America can be—together.

Happy Thanksgiving.